I’m not ashamed to say that my philosophy of composition is
already evolving from what I thought it was a few days ago. Last week, I believed
the expressive philosophy was the best way to go about teaching composition.
What appealed to me most was the emphasis being placed on the writer, rather
than the traditional idea of audience emphasis. As of now, my philosophy of
composition is a mimetic-rhetorical hybrid. In Richard Fulkerson’s Four Philosophies of Composition, he
notes that a mimetic philosophy is the connection between good writing and good
thinking. As we discuss in almost each class session, writing starts before a pen
is ever touched to paper. Without the ability to think critically and analyze,
your writing will be flat, one-dimensional and not a true reflection of the
world you live in. Something else to consider with the mimetic philosophy is its
emphasis on teaching sound reasoning as a best practice. In addition, the
ability to write well stems from knowledge already known and research performed
in pursuit of additional knowledge. So, the practical side of me can appreciate
the mimetic philosophy as I believe everyone, at all levels of education, has
the ability to work within this philosophy. The rhetorical composition
philosophy is also valuable to me because it emphasizes that writing is “good”
when it has been adapted to have the desired effect on an audience. This allows
us to include blogs, social media communications (Facebook, Twitter, etc.),
emails, and other forms of informal writing in what can be considered “good”
writing. Too often students are told that academic published works are the
examples of good writing that they should strive to emulate, but for many
students, they cannot relate to the texts they are assigned in the classroom. It
is more helpful to students to take foundational texts and apply the knowledge
they gain from them to situations they experience daily.
Here are the two values that are most important to me:
1. Teaching students
to learn for life, not just the classroom: When teaching students, don’t
assume that your influence over them ends after the last assignment is turned
in and grades are submitted. What would you like for students to take from a
course? How can they apply some of the knowledge they’ve learned to real-life
situations? I think this is especially important when working with K-12
students since many of them will not continue their formal learning at a
college or university. I also like to think of this as a student-oriented
approach.
2. Providing students
with a safe space and the appropriate atmosphere for learning: I want
students to approach learning in my class not just as a requirement, but also
as a way to safely express their ideas. After reading the BA1 essays from Texas
Tech’s First-Year Composition program, I was disheartened to see how many
students had been told they were bad writers. Many students even shared that
their previous instructors did not attempt to help them become better writers;
instead, instructors were more concerned about making sure they hit all of the
points that their state-approved lesson plans required of them. Some students
even wrote that they believed they were terrible writers and had no hope of
improving; in fact, the ultimate goal was to “just pass this class.” Fortunately,
I didn’t have any experiences like this in my high school years. All of the
teachers I had were caring professionals who were willing to go the extra mile
and make sure that each student was given the tools they needed to succeed.
I think this is an excellent philosophy. You clearly have a good idea of the way you need to teach students and I think you have hit one problem right on the head. It is a shame to see students talk about their former teachers that way but it does not surprise me. At the end of the day, passing the TAAS/TAKS/STAAR tests are all that really matters to teachers.
ReplyDeleteBut another problem also exists and I think it's that we have too many students and to few teachers. No teacher thinks they make enough money and that low pay salary is one reason people don't want to be teachers. With so few teachers we often see classes readily grow from sizes of 30+ students in each class. Detroit is or was considering cutting it's school system in half which would double most classes to over 60 students. With that many students it's hard to be able to help each individual student or even cater to the individual needs of the students. These are things that need to be addressed, unfortunately, I have to cede that the student-teacher ratio will get fixed much faster than an increase in salary.
Shayla, I like that you shed a little bit of attention to the K-12 aspect of education and that you've made it a point to make your classroom safe.
ReplyDeleteYou made a good point in saying that it is important to instill the craft of writing at the secondary level because there will be some students who will not go on to college. I feel like sometimes, we lose track of this, especially in the atmosphere we are at right now. To us, it would seem ridiculous to NOT go on and get a post-secondary degree, but there are many people out there who either do not desire to get a post-secondary education or, because of certain circumstances, just cannot do it. Your belief that these students should essentially not get left behind really resonates with me.
Also, I really admire that you believe that everyone is entitled to the same positive experience you had with learning writing. This is great!